inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #226 of 250: Bruce Sterling (bruces) Mon 18 Jan 21 06:30
permalink #226 of 250: Bruce Sterling (bruces) Mon 18 Jan 21 06:30
Our world has "we brought this on ourselves" disasters, and then it's got the dinosaur-killing comet variety of disasters. Climate-crisis disasters, and a pandemic like Covid-19, they both get a lot of blameworthy finger-pointing, recrimination, and guilt, but I kinda like the poetic, majestic purity of utterly nonhuman disasters. Last year, the ill-starred MMXX, there was a big "Gamma Ray Burst" through the solar system, known as "GRB 204015A." This was a powerful split-second flare at 4:42am U.S. Eastern Time on April 15, 2020. The flare missed the whole Earth but was detected by satellite instruments out around the orbit of Mars. It was a neutron-star eruption so violent that it moved-the-needle even though it arose from another galaxy eleven million light years away. The "Sculptor Galaxy," which abides in a different group of galaxies than the Milky Way's "Local Cluster." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sculptor_Galaxy So the Earth was attacked from another galaxy. Okay, not any major threat to us it might disturb a phone call or two, or two million phone calls, who knows but I dread to think what that massive disaster must have done to its own galaxy. The Sculptor Galaxy, it's a little livelier than ours, star-wise, but it's a perfectly decent-looking, respectable galaxy. Yet they have a"magnetar" whipping around at insane speeds and basically irradiating everything in the path of its wobbly, jittery gamma-ray-beam supernova levels of violence, but packed into a firehose, more or less.
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #227 of 250: Bruce Sterling (bruces) Mon 18 Jan 21 06:30
permalink #227 of 250: Bruce Sterling (bruces) Mon 18 Jan 21 06:30
Imagine that you're an artsy extraterrestrial civilization over in the "Sculptor Galaxy" and this chaotic monster cuts loose on your planet. Not a lot of wise policy decisions to be made about that prospect, really. You don't need to fret much over your disaster prepper supplies. I wonder what that event would look and feel like. Presumably it just peels the sky off in a fraction of a second, so likely there wouldn't be much grand, sublime spectacle to admire, but there's something Miltonian, Dantesque about it. It's so beyond normal astrophysics that it verges on metaphysics; even your Elon Musk Mars colony wouldn't escape the blast; probably even your Sun would be sucker-punched by the beam and would never be the same Sun again. And all because of a genuine "bad star," you know, a literal "dis-aster."
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #228 of 250: Bruce Sterling (bruces) Mon 18 Jan 21 06:32
permalink #228 of 250: Bruce Sterling (bruces) Mon 18 Jan 21 06:32
There's something calming about contemplating a disaster of this truly grand kind. I don't know why, but I can't find it frightening. It's like you're ranking the woes of your troubled world on a scale of one to ten and you realize that somewhere else there's a scale of a hundred thousand. Here's looking forward to State of the World episode 21.
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #229 of 250: Jon Lebkowsky (jonl) Mon 18 Jan 21 09:12
permalink #229 of 250: Jon Lebkowsky (jonl) Mon 18 Jan 21 09:12
I suppose, sometime in the barely imaginable future, someone will build a pizza joint in the middle of the remains of that Sculptor Galaxy neuron star.
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #230 of 250: Andrew Alden (alden) Mon 18 Jan 21 11:15
permalink #230 of 250: Andrew Alden (alden) Mon 18 Jan 21 11:15
The U.S. federal government has suffered a Katrina event. I hope the recovery to come will be carried out better than the one in New Orleans. There are disaster experts who show up after "natural disasters" (which are only human disasters due to insensate natural processes). Do we have competent experts on hand to advise us after this political disaster?
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #231 of 250: Elaine Sweeney (sweeney) Mon 18 Jan 21 11:28
permalink #231 of 250: Elaine Sweeney (sweeney) Mon 18 Jan 21 11:28
Another area where we have a significant event in our society is the COVID pandemic. There's a wide swath of the patient-facing sector of health care that is under risk of PTSD and burn-out. This also would be true of first responders and outlying areas like morticians. Tomorrow morning it seems clear the US will have hit 400,000 deaths and 24 million cases, and most likely 500,000 deaths by the end of February. I haven't heard of anyone or anything looking to address this aspect. It doesn't even get into the patients themselves or their families.
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #232 of 250: Elaine Sweeney (sweeney) Mon 18 Jan 21 12:04
permalink #232 of 250: Elaine Sweeney (sweeney) Mon 18 Jan 21 12:04
I can't imagine the sort of hours these people have worked, with what sort of lack of equipment, and some of them have been asked to do battlefield-type triage, due to lack of staff, resources or oxygen.
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #233 of 250: Brian Slesinsky (bslesins) Tue 19 Jan 21 12:18
permalink #233 of 250: Brian Slesinsky (bslesins) Tue 19 Jan 21 12:18
When grim milestones are announced, I wonder if we've hit the halfway point on deaths yet. I guess the halfway point will be close to the end, when the exponential curve turns into something else. It still looks exponential, though.
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #234 of 250: Jon Lebkowsky (jonl) Tue 19 Jan 21 13:40
permalink #234 of 250: Jon Lebkowsky (jonl) Tue 19 Jan 21 13:40
Possibly exponential, but hard to assess the impact of the vaccine at this point, and of new strategies and tactics from the Biden administration. OTOH we have potential increases in the R0, evidently because of new strains that are more infectious. Not sure how to model a prediction, given uncertainties.
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #235 of 250: Virtual Sea Monkey (karish) Tue 19 Jan 21 13:47
permalink #235 of 250: Virtual Sea Monkey (karish) Tue 19 Jan 21 13:47
The number of new infections grows exponentially as long as Rt, the effective reproduction number, is greater than one. Rt is a factor of the constant k in the growth equation: r(t) = e**kt + C
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #236 of 250: Jennifer Powell (jnfr) Tue 19 Jan 21 15:35
permalink #236 of 250: Jennifer Powell (jnfr) Tue 19 Jan 21 15:35
I'm definitely feeling a bit more hopeful today. And every time one of us gets their shots, I cheer.
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #237 of 250: Malka Older (malka) Wed 20 Jan 21 04:24
permalink #237 of 250: Malka Older (malka) Wed 20 Jan 21 04:24
Jane, thank you for your kind words in #215; they helped me feel better about the presentation, although I think it's a topic I need to continue to work on and refine. It's difficult applying the logic of academic rigor and rationality to a talk that is in part critiquing same. One of the questions I got at said presentation (technical aside, in case the idea is useful to anyone: after my talk the organizers put me in a breakout room while the students discussed their questions, organized them into themed groups, and chose spokespeople for each theme, after which I was brought back into the main zoom) was whether history repeats itself or we are living through something new, and it seems an apt question to bring up here. My answer (like my answer to the question of whether we're living in a utopia or a dystopia) was both (or neither). One hundred-odd years after a pandemic, looking at the newspaper articles from that time about people wearing masks or refusing to, it's hard not to feel a certain cyclicality; and yet, looking at, oh, vaccine timelines or virtual work, art, and connections, or even the inadequate but existent considerations of how to provide the vaccines for the countries whose governments can't afford it, we are in a very different place.
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #238 of 250: Malka Older (malka) Wed 20 Jan 21 04:26
permalink #238 of 250: Malka Older (malka) Wed 20 Jan 21 04:26
Meanwhile, the inauguration is in a few hours, draped in extensive, highly militarized security. I really hope that it will be free from disruption and violence. If it is, there will be hot takes of the "See? The threat was exaggerated" variety. Reactions like that after swine flu etc are part of why we were so terribly underprepared for covid: "the low-/medium-/high-probability disaster didn't happen this time therefore it won't happen" is not solid reasoning.And of course the preparedness itself affects how bad the impacts of the event are (which is part of why emergency management/disaster risk reduction is such a thankless job: if it goes well, no one notices). In this case that's particularly true because of the heavy deterrence approach. Anyway, let's hope annoying hot takes are the worst consequence.
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #239 of 250: Jon Lebkowsky (jonl) Wed 20 Jan 21 05:48
permalink #239 of 250: Jon Lebkowsky (jonl) Wed 20 Jan 21 05:48
I woke this morning realizing that insurgents were unlikely to attempt an attack when it's expected and when a deterrent is in place. A lack of protest or rioting today won't mean we've seen the last of them. On the other hand, the catalyzing presence of Q might fade, and take with it some of the energy fueling the protests. As Trump always said, "We'll see what happens."
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #240 of 250: George Mokray (jonl) Wed 20 Jan 21 05:49
permalink #240 of 250: George Mokray (jonl) Wed 20 Jan 21 05:49
Via email form George Mokray: Italo Calvino meets Martin Luther King Jr <https://www.brainpickings.org/2017/02/13/italo-calvino-racism/> Calvinos posthumously published writings on his visit to the USA may be useful to a certain Texan in Turin, a sort of turnabout mirror to mirror.
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #241 of 250: Kevin Gould (jonl) Wed 20 Jan 21 05:49
permalink #241 of 250: Kevin Gould (jonl) Wed 20 Jan 21 05:49
Via email from Kevin Gould: I'm enjoying your eloquent rants and rambles. Please continue.
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #242 of 250: Jon Lebkowsky (jonl) Thu 21 Jan 21 10:57
permalink #242 of 250: Jon Lebkowsky (jonl) Thu 21 Jan 21 10:57
Joe Biden is the USA's new leader, and he's actually working pretty hard. Looking at all he's doing and all he has to do, I fall into a state of near exhaustion just considering it all. We've already re-committed to the World Health Organization and sent (virtual) Fauci to meet with 'em. Biden signed 17 executive orders his first day, many of them intended to undo damage from the last administration. Meanwhile there'll be no Trump china: <https://www.cnn.com/2021/01/21/politics/trump-white-house-china/index.html> This is too bad, because I was envisioning a "bull in the china shop" design. Oh,well...
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #243 of 250: Elaine Sweeney (sweeney) Thu 21 Jan 21 11:31
permalink #243 of 250: Elaine Sweeney (sweeney) Thu 21 Jan 21 11:31
I have a vague curiosity what Trump will have for his official portrait. I don't suppose it would be one of Jon McNaughton bombastic works, though that would be fitting.
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #244 of 250: Angie Coiro (coiro) Thu 21 Jan 21 11:34
permalink #244 of 250: Angie Coiro (coiro) Thu 21 Jan 21 11:34
It can be cold and quick: a poop emoji.
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #245 of 250: Elaine Sweeney (sweeney) Thu 21 Jan 21 16:15
permalink #245 of 250: Elaine Sweeney (sweeney) Thu 21 Jan 21 16:15
Personally I like this one: <https://www.instagram.com/p/CKSDdCXh8w7/>
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #246 of 250: Jon Lebkowsky (jonl) Fri 22 Jan 21 06:49
permalink #246 of 250: Jon Lebkowsky (jonl) Fri 22 Jan 21 06:49
I thought we might have more to say following the inauguration, hence the extension of the State of the World an extra week - but we're not particularly active now. I want to thank <bruces> and <malka> for joining and contributing, as well as all the others who've posted here, and contributed via email. Each State of the World conversation is in what we call a 'topic' on the WELL, in what we call a 'conference' called <inkwell.vue.>. If you're reading this and you're not a member of the WELL, but would like to join conversations like this, please consider joining: <https://www.well.com/join/> We don't have to end the conversation now, though I think our guests have dropped off. Members of the WELL should feel free to keep posting observations here. If you're not a member of the WELL, you can send an email to inkwell at well.com - we'll continue to post those through Monday, January 25. Let's hope for a relatively boring but consequential 2021.
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #247 of 250: Ari Davidow (ari) Fri 22 Jan 21 08:42
permalink #247 of 250: Ari Davidow (ari) Fri 22 Jan 21 08:42
amen
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #248 of 250: Jennifer Powell (jnfr) Fri 22 Jan 21 13:50
permalink #248 of 250: Jennifer Powell (jnfr) Fri 22 Jan 21 13:50
Thanks, Jon.
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #249 of 250: Andrew Alden (alden) Fri 22 Jan 21 16:19
permalink #249 of 250: Andrew Alden (alden) Fri 22 Jan 21 16:19
Nice to have some extra perspective during a tumultuous time.
inkwell.vue.510
:
State of the World 2021
permalink #250 of 250: Jane Hirshfield (jh) Fri 22 Jan 21 23:21
permalink #250 of 250: Jane Hirshfield (jh) Fri 22 Jan 21 23:21
Grateful to all here for the conversation, and Malka's closing comment and passing along of the question without single answer--I got caught up in inauguration watching and aftermath, and didn't see it until now. It is indeed such a great relief to see the new year finally fully started. May the next State of the World conversation find some of the current hopes bearing fruit.
Members: Enter the conference to participate. All posts made in this conference are world-readable.